The Beginner’s Guide to Cigar Ratings and What They Mean in 2026
Cigarwell OfficialAuthor
4 min read
If you are new to cigars, one of the first confusing things you will notice is the numbering system. Everywhere online, cigars are rated from 0 to 100. One cigar scores a 92. Another an 88. And suddenly, people are debating what those numbers truly represent.
Understanding cigar ratings helps beginners make smarter choices, avoid disappointment, and select cigars that better match their palate.
This guide breaks down the rating system in simple terms, explains how experts score cigars, and shows you how to use ratings wisely — without depending on them entirely.
What Are Cigar Ratings?
Cigar ratings are numerical scores given after blind tastings. Experts evaluate:
- Construction
- Flavor
- Burn
- Aroma
- Strength
- Overall balance
Most major publications use a 100-point scale, though cigars rarely score above 95.
These ratings help smokers understand quality and consistency — but they are not absolute rules. They are informed opinions from trained reviewers.
Who Rates Cigars?
Ratings typically come from professional publications, review panels, and experienced media outlets.
Cigar Aficionado
The most recognized publication in the cigar world. Their blind tasting panels rate hundreds of cigars annually. A high score here often increases demand and price.
Cigar Journal
Known for its international tasting panel, Cigar Journal highlights both boutique and major brands. Their reviews are respected for neutrality and balance.
Influencers and Online Reviewers
YouTubers, bloggers, and social media reviewers also score cigars. Their reviews are often more casual and relatable for beginners.
How the 100-Point Cigar Rating Scale Works
Cigars are graded similarly to wine or whiskey. Here is a simplified breakdown:
95–100: Exceptional
Flawless construction, refined flavors, superior balance. Rare and often limited. Usually expensive and complex.
90–94: Outstanding
Well-crafted, consistent, and impressive. Many smokers consider this range the sweet spot for quality and value.
85–89: Very Good
Reliable and enjoyable. Great everyday cigars, especially for beginners.
80–84: Average to Good
Decent performance but may have minor flaws like uneven burn or limited complexity.
79 and Below: Below Average
Noticeable construction or flavor issues. Rarely recommended.
What Reviewers Look For When Rating a Cigar
A rating is not random. Reviewers follow structured criteria.
Construction Quality
Appearance, firmness, wrapper condition, and overall craftsmanship.
Burn Characteristics
Even burn line, ash structure, temperature control, and smoke output.
Draw Performance
The draw should feel smooth and effortless. Too tight or too loose reduces the score.
Flavor Complexity
Depth, transitions, and clarity of notes such as cedar, espresso, cocoa, pepper, or dried fruit.
Aroma
Pleasant, sweet, or spicy aromas can positively influence the score.
Balance and Strength
Strength must match flavor. Too harsh or overwhelming lowers the rating.
Overall Impression
The reviewer’s total experience from first draw to final inch.
How Beginners Should Use Cigar Ratings
Ratings are helpful — but they should not control your choices.
Use Ratings to Avoid Low Quality Cigars
Scores below 83 often indicate flaws. Beginners can use ratings to avoid poorly constructed cigars.
Start With the 86–92 Range
This range offers reliable, approachable cigars that are not overly strong or expensive.
Compare Ratings With Your Own Experience
Smoke first. Check the rating afterward. This helps you understand your personal preferences.
Avoid Chasing 95+ Scores
High scores don’t guarantee enjoyment. These cigars may be too complex or too strong for beginners.
Read the Notes, Not Just the Number
Flavor descriptions and strength levels matter more than the final score.
Common Misconceptions About Cigar Ratings
Myth: High Ratings Mean Strong Cigars
False. Mild cigars can score 92+ if balanced and flavorful.
Myth: Reviewers Favor Expensive Cigars
Many top-rated cigars cost under $10. Quality, not price, determines score.
Myth: Ratings Are Universal
Different publications have different palates. A 90 from one source may be 87 from another.
Myth: Ratings Predict Your Taste
Cigars are subjective. You may prefer an 85-rated cigar over a 93.
Why Ratings Matter in the Cigar World
Though imperfect, ratings influence the industry in meaningful ways.
They Guide Beginners
Especially helpful when buying cigars online without physically inspecting them.
They Influence Demand
A 90+ score often causes cigars to sell out quickly.
They Encourage Quality
Consistent scoring pushes manufacturers to maintain high standards.
Beginner-Friendly Cigars That Often Score Well
Some cigars consistently earn strong ratings while remaining approachable.
Mild and Flavorful Options
- Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real
- Oliva Connecticut Reserve
- Perdomo Champagne
Medium-Bodied Favorites
- My Father Flor de Las Antillas
- Rocky Patel Vintage
- AJ Fernandez New World
Boutique Brands With Strong Scores
- Foundation
- Caldwell
- Southern Draw
These brands combine accessibility with quality and often appeal to beginners.
How Rating Systems May Evolve in 2025 and Beyond
As cigar culture grows online, rating systems are becoming more dynamic.
More Blind Tasting Panels
To reduce bias and improve consistency.
More Accessible Flavor Charts
Flavor wheels and aroma maps help beginners understand tasting notes.
More Community-Driven Ratings
User reviews and digital platforms increasingly influence buying decisions.
Final Thoughts
Cigar ratings are a helpful starting point, but they should not dictate your entire journey.
Use ratings as a map, not a rulebook. They help avoid low-quality cigars and highlight consistent performers. Still, the best education comes from personal experience.
Smoke different profiles. Compare notes. Discover what fits your palate.
That is how you build a confident and enjoyable cigar journey.